“How Crazy is too Crazy to be Executed?” (I prefer to say: Mentally ill … not “crazy”)


Severe Mental Illness

Severe Mental Illness (Photo credit: homelesshub)

http://sentencing.typepad.com/sentencing_law_and_policy/2013/02/how-crazy-is-too-crazy-to-be-executed.html

please, see the Article in Mother Jones, too!

“How Crazy Is Too Crazy to Be Executed?”

The question in the title of this post is the main headline of this new Mother Jones essay authored by capital defense attorney Marc Bookman.  The lengthy piece carries this summary subheadline: “The voices told Andre Thomas to gouge out his eyes. But  even that hasn’t convinced the state of Texas to reconsider his death  sentence.”

This companion piece, also authored by Marc Bookman, is headlined ” 13 Men Condemned to Die Despite Severe Mental Illness: If juveniles and intellectually disabled people are ineligible for execution, why not paranoid schizophrenics?”.   Here is how that piece gets started as an introduction to summaries of 13 capital cases involving defendants with severe mental illness:

Just how crazy must a person be to be ruled incompetent for execution in the United States?  Being profoundly mentally ill is not enough. You have to be deemed legally “insane.” At trial, the insanity defense generally hinges on a person’s inability to distinguish right from wrong or understand the “nature and quality” of his act.  In the context of an impending execution, insanity means you cannot rationally comprehend that you are being put to death as a consequence of the crime you committed.

In 2005, a Texas jury found that Andre Thomas, the subject of my in-depth companion piece (see box below), was not insane at the time of his crime. To put this in context, consider that Thomas was then, and still is, a delusional paranoid schizophrenic who hears voices — from God, he believes — telling him to do things.  He carved out the organs of his four-year-old son, his estranged wife, and her 13-month-old daughter, and took them home in his pockets, believing that this would kill the demons inside them.  In the days following his arrest, he insisted to a jailhouse nurse that his victims were still alive.

And that’s not even the weirdest part of the story. Thomas’ case is on appeal in federal court, and as it stands, the courts cannot even address the question of whether he is competent to be executed until he is about to be.   But should someone as obviously crazy as Andre Thomas be facing execution at all?   Over the past decade, US courts have barred the death penalty for the intellectually disabled and for juveniles — the Supreme Court found that they have less culpability due to their lower mental functioning and immaturity. Many legal observers believe that barring the death penalty for the severely mentally ill, given their dissociation from reality, is the next frontier in capital jurisprudence.

Over the years, governors from both parties have seen fit to commute the death sentences of profoundly mentally ill prisoners, even in conservative states. But authorities in Texas have shown little mercy: The state Board of Pardons and Paroles has recommended clemency based on mental illness in only one case since 1977, when the death penalty came back into use (see Kelsey Patterson below) — and Gov. Rick Perry denied it.

February 12, 2013 at 05:35 PM | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451574769e2017ee8769062970d

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference “How Crazy Is Too Crazy to Be Executed?”:

pending executions february 2013


Judge Thomas J. Devine

Judge Thomas J. Devine (Photo credit: SMU Central University Libraries)

Got this information by e-mail from LOST IN THE SYSTEM – thank You!

Pending Executions February 2013

by LOST IN THE SYSTEM

See on Scoop.it – CIRCLE OF HOPE

Pending Executions February 2013

Circle of Hope’s insight:

13* Chris Sepulvado        Louisiana

21* Carl Blue Texas

26* Paul Howell Florida

27   Larry Swearingen Texas

 

CHRIS SEPULVADO  – LOUISIANA EXECUTION DATE 13TH JANUARY 2013

Gov Contact details

http://www.gov.louisiana.gov/index.cfm?md=form&tmp=email_governor

 

Louisiana Board of Pardons

504 Mayflower Street, Bldg 6

Baton Rouge, LA 70802

Phone: 225/342-5421

Fax: 225/342-2289

 

———————————————————-

 

CARL BLUE – TEXAS – EXECUTION DATE 21ST February 2013

Gov Contact details

http://governor.state.tx.us/contact/

 

 

 

 

Office of the Governor

P.O. Box 12428

Austin, Texas 78711-2428

 

 

 

Information and Referral Hotline [for Texas callers] :

(800) 843-5789

 

Information and Referral and Opinion Hotline [for Austin, Texas and out-of-state callers] :

(512) 463-1782

 

Office of the Governor Main Switchboard :

(512) 463-2000

 

Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles

8610 Shoal Creek Blvd

Austin, TX 78757

Phone: 512/406-5852

Fax: 512/467- 0945

 

please sign the petition

http://www.change.org/en-GB/petitions/stop-the-execution-of-carl-blue-commute-his-sentence-to-life-in-priso

 

——————————————————-

 

PAUL HOWELL – FLORIDA – EXECUTION DATE 26TH FEBRUARY 2013

 

http://www.flgov.com/contact-gov-scott/

 

 

Florida Governor Rick Scott

The Capitol

Tallahassee, FL 32399-0001

Fax:(850)487-0801

Tel:(850)488-7146 11/02

 

 

Florida Parole Commission

4070 Esplanade Way

Tallahassee, Florida 32399

Phone: 850/488-2952

Fax: 850/488-0695

 

————————————————————

 

LARRY SWEARINGEN – TEXAS – EXECUTION DATE 27TH FEBRUARY 2013

Gov Contact details

http://governor.state.tx.us/contact/

 

 

Office of the Governor

P.O. Box 12428

Austin, Texas 78711-2428

 

Information and Referral Hotline [for Texas callers] :

(800) 843-5789

 

Information and Referral and Opinion Hotline [for Austin, Texas and out-of-state callers] :

(512) 463-1782

 

Office of the Governor Main Switchboard :

(512) 463-2000

 

Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles

8610 Shoal Creek Blvd

Austin, TX 78757

Phone: 512/406-5852

Fax: 512/467- 0945

Bringing people out of shadow – of nameless shadow: Annamaria

Prosecutor Faces Justice


http://www.nytimes.com/2012/11/13/opinion/nocera-a-texas-prosecutor-faces-justice.html?smid=tw-share

some lines here:

Op-Ed Columnist

<NYT_BYLINE>

<NYT_TEXT><NYT_CORRECTION_TOP>In just about a month from now, Texas will witness a rare event: a former prosecutor is going to be held to account for alleged prosecutorial misconduct.

Opinion Twitter Logo.

Connect With Us on Twitter

For Op-Ed, follow @nytopinion and to hear from the editorial page editor, Andrew Rosenthal, follow @andyrNYT.

He is Ken Anderson, who for nearly 17 years was the district attorney in Williamson County, a fast-growing suburb of Austin. (In 2002, Gov. Rick Perry made him a district judge.) As Pamela Colloff writes, in a brilliant two-part series in Texas Monthly, Anderson was the kind of prosecutor who “routinely asked for, and won, harsh sentences and fought to keep offenders in prison long after they became eligible for parole.”